..........Contact me at Mom25dogs@gmail.com.........

Contact me at Mom25dogs@gmail.com

Monday, October 14, 2013

Lost Girls by Robert Kolker

I just finished reading Robert Kolker's Lost Girls, An Unsolved American Mystery about the Oak Beach murders.

In December 2010, four sets of human remains – neatly shrouded in burlap sacks – were discovered along remote Gilgo Beach in Long Island. Further searches found the remains of 10 people between Manorville and Oak Beach, one a toddler and one an Asian male in women's clothes. The other eight were women. The book had no photos which would have been appreciated. But here are photos of the principal places and people for your help.

The old Oak Beach Inn

The search

Maureen Brainard-Barnes

Melissa Barthelemy

Shannan Gilbert

Megan Waterman

Amber Overstreet Costello

Jessica Taylor

Joseph Joe Brewer

His house

Dr. Charles Peter Hackett

His house

Gus Coletti

Michael Pak, the driver

Kimberly "Kim" Overstreet Costello

Lorraine Ela and her mother, Muriel Benner

Mari Gilbert

This could have been a very confusing story with all the different people and situations involved but Kolker did a good job in bringing some order to it. Using a chapter for each woman we got to know a little about their lives before the murders. Each tale so tragic.

These women got themselves into a terrible lifestyle of prostitution, drugs, lies and theft. But no one deserves to be treated like so much trash to be used, abused, murdered and thrown away. I hope they find whoever did this.

Of course, the mystery has not been solved and so there is no end to the story, no conclusion, no closure. And the police cannot reveal all they may know or the evidence they may have so the story is one sided. They cannot make comments on an open case. I understand that but it made the book more rumor than facts.

I could have done without the conflict in the families that he describes. Such tragedy can bring out the best and the worst. It's their business and didn't need to be made public. That made the book too long. Maybe he didn't have enough material without it to make a book?

I can only pray for these families and for justice.


Anonymous said...

I never seen such a bigger travesty of justice than with the Long Island Serial Killer case. Outrageous how the FBI was brought in, not to solve the case, but to help cover it up!

Unknown said...

Can you please explain what the cover up is all about? I'm new to the details of this case and would like to understand what was covered up, why it was and for who. If you have time

Anonymous said...

Leave it to long Island lawless enforcement to screw up a case,, or was it a cover up to protect the chief detective now imprisoned?

Anonymous said...


How did you know that the FBI was brought In to cover it up
You are 100% correct. Absolutely.
Not only was the FBI brought in to cover it up,
Loretta Lynch was the U.S. Attorney at the time
and she covered it up, which makes you really wonder.

And that slime ball John Ray was intentionally PUT in the case
to be a fixer - and cover-up - only to PRETEND to be seeing Hackett;
and that guy who wrote the book Lost Girls - he also is covering up.

He altered some material in the book and lied to the public, and in
doing so, he is covering up Pak's involvement.

Anonymous said...

Where is the money shannon gilbert made the night she disappeared was it in her wallet when they found her purse n wallet n where is her cellphone did they ever find her cell phone

My Most Popular Posts

Total Pageviews

Contact Me

To contact me, email me at Mom25dogs@gmail.com